etfpick.me

CLO ETFs vs. SGOV: What's the Catch Behind the Extra Yield?

Comparison · Nov 16, 2026 · 9 min read

ETF Pick team

#CLO#CLO ETF#JAAA#JBBB#SGOV#T-bills#floating rate#cash alternativeRead in Korean →

Contents ▾

If you park cash in T-bill ETFs like SGOV, you've probably seen CLO ETFs pitched as the upgrade: about the same low risk, roughly 1 percentage point more yield. 🤔 Extra yield almost never comes free, though. So what's the catch, and what exactly is a CLO? In this post we'll start with how CLOs work, compare the six largest CLO ETFs, and use the data to see what you give up for that extra yield compared with T-bill ETFs like SGOV. 📚

🧱 What's a CLO, anyway?

A CLO (Collateralized Loan Obligation) is a bond backed by a pool of a few hundred corporate loans, paid off from the interest those loans generate.

  1. 🏢 Companies with below-investment-grade credit borrow from banks (these are called leveraged loans)
  2. 🧺 A manager pools roughly 150 to 300 of these loans into one basket: the CLO
  3. 🪜 The basket is sliced into layers, or tranches, from AAA down through BB and finally equity at the bottom
  4. 💵 Interest from the loans is paid from the top layer down, and losses hit from the bottom layer up

Think of it as a stack of cups filled from the top. 🥤 Water (interest) fills the top cup first, and if there isn't enough, the bottom cup runs dry first.

So two CLO investments can carry completely different risk depending on which tranche you own.

TrancheInterestTakes lossesBehaves like
🥇 AAALowestLastShort-term bonds
🥈 AA·AA bit moreNextInvestment-grade corporates
🥉 BBB·BB·BHighEarlyHigh-yield bonds
⚠️ EquityHighestFirstStocks

Two things are worth remembering.

  • 🔄 It's floating rate. CLO coupons reset regularly at a base rate (SOFR) plus a spread. When rates rise, the coupon rises too, so prices don't drop the way long-term Treasuries do.
  • 🛡️ AAA tranches have never defaulted. According to S&P, no US or European CLO tranche originally rated AAA has defaulted.

The name sounds like the CDOs (bundles of mortgages) behind the 2008 crisis, but CLOs hold corporate loans instead. Still, "never defaulted" doesn't mean "never drops in price." We'll get to that. ⚖️

Search CLO ETF to see the US-listed funds.

📋 The six largest CLO ETFs

Six CLO ETFs hold more than about $750 million. By the tranches they buy, they split into four AAA funds and two BBB·B funds.

ETFIssuerMain tranchesNet assetsExpense ratioLaunched
JAAAJanus HendersonAAA$32.4B0.20%Oct 2020
PAAAPGIMAAA$15.3B0.19%Jul 2023
CLOAiShares (BlackRock)AAA$2.8B0.20%Jan 2023
CLOIVanEckAAA-focused investment grade$1.8B0.29%Jun 2022
JBBBJanus HendersonBBB·BB$1.5B0.47%Jan 2022
CLOZEldridgeBBB·BB·B$0.78B0.50%Jan 2023
For reference: SGOViShares0 to 3 month US Treasuries$117.1B0.09%May 2020

(As of November 13, 2026)

💵 How much extra income do you get?

Let's start with the question everyone asks: yields and total returns over the past year.

ETF12-month yield1-year total return3-year total return1-year price change
SGOV (baseline)3.63%3.76%14.10%+0.06%
BIL3.67%3.70%13.83%(almost none)
JAAA4.81%4.82%19.08%-0.10%
PAAA4.62%4.87%19.73%+0.14%
CLOA4.74%4.89%19.43%+0.04%
CLOI5.04%5.09%20.82%-0.08%
JBBB6.23%4.04%24.22%-2.17%
CLOZ7.15%4.84%26.65%-2.32%

(Close of November 13, 2026, total return with distributions reinvested. Yields are pre-tax, all paid monthly)

  • 🥇 The AAA funds earned about 1 percentage point more than SGOV over the year. Over three years it's SGOV +14.1% against JAAA +19.1%, a gap of about 5 points.
  • 📉 AAA fund prices barely moved. Yield and total return are almost identical, so nearly all the interest stayed in your pocket.
  • ⚠️ The BBB·B funds yield 6% to 7%, but their 1-year total return was similar to the AAA funds. Prices fell more than 2%, eating into those bigger payouts.
  • 🚀 Over three years, though, the BBB·B funds earned the most, thanks to big gains in 2023 and 2024.

📅 How did they do year by year?

ETF20222023202420252026 (through Nov 13)
SGOV (baseline)+1.58%+5.12%+5.27%+4.24%+3.22%
JAAA+0.49%+8.58%+7.42%+5.16%+3.99%
PAAA(not listed)(not listed)+7.47%+5.37%+4.19%
CLOA(not listed)(partial year)+7.25%+5.44%+4.17%
CLOI(not listed)+8.94%+8.26%+5.83%+4.28%
JBBB(partial year)+16.89%+10.71%+4.39%+3.22%
CLOZ(not listed)(partial year)+11.85%+5.97%+3.79%
For reference: AGG (US aggregate bonds)-13.02%+5.65%+1.31%+7.19%-1.52%

(Total return with distributions reinvested)

  • 🔥 JAAA stayed positive through the 2022 rate shock (+0.49%). The US aggregate bond ETF AGG lost 13% that year. Floating rates made the difference.
  • 🐢 It still trailed SGOV (+1.58%) in 2022, because recession worries widened spreads and pushed prices down for a while.
  • 🎁 It made that back in 2023 and 2024, as spreads tightened, prices recovered, and the high coupons kept coming.

🌩️ What happens when markets get rough?

The real difference between CLOs and T-bills shows up in a crisis. Here are three recent selloffs and each fund's max drawdown.

ETFMar 2023 SVB crisis2025 tariff selloffNov 5, 2026Max drawdownVolatility (3 yr)
SPY (S&P 500)-2.42%-18.76%-4.41%-24.50%15.41%
SGOV+0.14%+0.56%0.00%-0.03%0.22%
JAAA-0.66%-0.44%0.00%-2.64%1.20%
PAAA(not listed)-0.09%+0.02%-1.04%0.95%
CLOA-0.35%-0.49%-0.04%-1.34%1.15%
CLOI-0.44%-1.72%+0.02%-3.25%2.61%
JBBB-3.10%-3.12%-0.16%-10.79%3.63%
CLOZ-1.10%-5.32%-0.08%-5.32%3.72%

(Total return with distributions reinvested. Max drawdown from October 25, 2021, or launch, through November 13, 2026)

  • 🛡️ SGOV actually went up during selloffs. Treasuries are where money runs when it gets scared.
  • 🥇 The AAA funds dipped about half a percent. Not much, but negative, unlike SGOV.
  • 🥉 The BBB·B funds swung a lot more. JBBB fell as much as -10.79% in 2022 and took about nine months (until July 2023) to recover. CLOZ lost 5.32% in the tariff selloff.
  • 🧊 There was a bigger crisis before our data starts. In the March 2020 COVID crash, reports described even AAA CLOs being marked down sharply in a market with plenty of sellers and few buyers. Nothing defaulted, but anyone forced to sell then would have taken a loss.

AAA CLOs carry very little default risk, but real price risk. SGOV carries almost neither. ⚖️

⚖️ CLO ETFs instead of SGOV: pros and cons

👍 Pros of AAA CLO ETFs

  • 💵 About 1 point more income. On $100,000 for a year, that's roughly $1,000 more (pre-tax, based on the past year).
  • 🔄 Rate risk stays small, like SGOV. Floating coupons mean rising rates don't knock prices down much.
  • 🛡️ AAA tranches have no default record, because the layers below absorb losses first.

👎 Cons of AAA CLO ETFs

  • 🌩️ Prices can drop in a crisis, right when you might need the money most. SGOV rose in those moments.
  • 💧 Selling can get harder in an extreme crisis. The CLO market trades far less than Treasuries, so the ETF can trade below the value of what it holds.
  • 💸 Fees are about double. SGOV is 0.09%, the AAA funds 0.19% to 0.29%, and the BBB·B funds 0.47% to 0.50%.
  • 🧩 It's complicated. You can't realistically check each loan inside the fund yourself.

🥉 Treat BBB·B funds (JBBB, CLOZ) separately

  • They're closer to high-yield bonds than to a cash substitute. The yield is high, but they can fall close to 10% when the economy turns.

For the Treasury side, try searching Treasury bills or floating rate bonds. 🔍

🧭 So when does each one make sense?

Here's how the data sorts it out.

AAA funds can fit when 👍

  • 🅿️ You have cash you won't need for six months or more and want a bit more than SGOV pays
  • 🔄 You're unsure where rates are going and don't want long-term bond risk
  • 🧩 You want to split cash between SGOV and a CLO fund to nudge up the yield

SGOV is the better fit when 👍

  • 🚨 It's emergency money you might need any day (money that can't be down in a crisis)
  • 📉 It's cash waiting to buy stocks on a dip (CLOs can fall at the same moment)

BBB·B funds can fit when 👍

  • 💰 You want higher income and can live with drops of around 10% on part of your bond allocation

⚠️ Check before you invest

  • 🧾 Taxes differ. CLO ETF distributions are generally taxed as ordinary income. Treasury interest from funds like SGOV is generally exempt from state income tax; CLO income isn't. Check each fund's tax documents, and remember tax rules can change.
  • 📉 Lower rates mean lower income. Both CLOs and T-bills float, so when the Fed cuts, the payouts shrink too.
  • 🪜 Similar names, different tranches. AAA funds and BBB·B funds are completely different products. Check for "AAA" or "BBB" in the name.
  • 📜 Read the prospectus for each fund's rating mix and strategy.

Past returns and distributions don't guarantee future results.

🎁 The takeaway

A CLO ETF is a floating-rate bond fund that buys a chosen layer of pooled corporate loans. The big AAA funds (JAAA, PAAA, CLOA, CLOI) earned about 1 point a year more than SGOV and held up through rising rates, but they dipped in selloffs when SGOV didn't. The BBB·B funds pay 6% to 7% but move like high-yield bonds. The data points to a simple split: SGOV for money you might need now, AAA CLOs for part of the cash you won't touch for a while. 😊

Curious about more CLO funds? Ask the search page something like "CLO ETF" or "floating rate income." 🚀