etfpick.me

Managed Futures ETFs: 2022's Heroes, and the Three Years After

Comparison · Nov 20, 2026 · 10 min read

ETF Pick team

#managed futures#CTA#trend following#DBMF#KMLM#alternatives#crisis alpha#diversificationRead in Korean →

Contents ▾

2022 was brutal for almost everyone. The S&P 500 fell 24.5% peak to trough, and even the "safe" US aggregate bond market (AGG) lost 14.4%. Yet a handful of ETFs gained 30% to nearly 50% over the same stretch: managed futures ETFs. 📈 In our tail risk hedge post, managed futures were the clear winner in the long 2022 bear market. This time we'll start with the CTA strategy behind them, compare the six largest managed futures ETFs, and use the data to see what happened to 2022's heroes over the next three years. 📚

🧭 What's a CTA strategy?

To understand managed futures, you first need to know what a CTA is.

A CTA (Commodity Trading Advisor) is a US term for a professional manager that trades futures on behalf of clients. CTAs register with the CFTC and join the National Futures Association (NFA). Despite the "commodity" in the name, most now trade far more than raw materials: stock index, bond and currency futures too. Funds run by CTAs are collectively called managed futures.

The most common CTA approach is trend following.

  1. 📊 Watch prices across dozens of futures markets every day (oil, gold, Treasuries, the yen, stock indexes and more)
  2. ⬆️ Go long markets that have been rising
  3. ⬇️ Go short markets that have been falling. Futures let you sell first, so you can profit from declines too
  4. 🔁 Flip when the trend flips. Most of this runs on preset rules (algorithms) rather than gut calls

Think of it as a sailboat that turns its sail toward the wind. ⛵ Whichever way the wind (trend) blows, it goes with it. But when the wind keeps shifting, it spends all its time turning the sail and goes nowhere.

That gives CTA strategies a distinct personality.

  • 🐢 Strong in slow, persistent trends. In a year like 2022, when rates rose all year and bonds fell all year, they made big money. The SG CTA Index, which tracks 20 large CTAs, was reported up about 20% that year, and the trend-only SG Trend Index about 27%.
  • 🌩️ Weak in sudden crashes. A selloff that's over in a day or two passes before any trend shows up.
  • 🌊 They lose in choppy markets. Buy the breakout and it reverses, short the breakdown and it bounces. That "whipsaw" adds up.
  • 🧊 Often called "crisis alpha" because they tend to earn in crises. Trend followers are widely reported to have been positive in the 2008 financial crisis as well.

CTA funds used to be hedge-fund style products with high minimums. Now you can buy them like a stock in an ETF. Search managed futures to see what's listed.

📋 The six largest managed futures ETFs

Six managed futures ETFs hold more than $250 million. The names sound alike, but how they package the CTA strategy varies a lot.

ETFIssuerNet assetsExpense ratioLaunchedHow it works
DBMFiMGP (DBi)$1.68B0.85%May 2019🪞 Replicates the returns of 20 large CTAs
CTASimplify$1.17B0.91%Mar 2022🧩 Four models incl. trend and carry, commodities and rates only
KMLMKraneShares$0.57B0.90%Dec 2020📏 Pure trend following on 22 futures, no equity futures
IMFInvesco$0.31B0.80%Mar 2025📡 Trend signals across about 50 markets
FMFFirst Trust$0.29B0.98%Aug 2013⚖️ Commodities 50%, currencies 25%, equities 25%
WTMFWisdomTree$0.25B0.65%Jan 2011📈 Trend following plus up to 40% equity futures

(As of November 19, 2026. Expense ratios can differ by source)

  • 🪞 DBMF is "copy the hedge funds." It looks at large CTAs' last 60 days of returns and builds a futures mix that would have produced similar results, without hedge fund fees.
  • 📏 KMLM is rules-only trend following. It trades 11 commodity, 6 currency and 5 bond futures and no stock futures at all.
  • 🧩 CTA blends more than trend. It adds carry (reading the yield curve), mean reversion and a risk-off model.
  • 📈 WTMF and FMF hold stock futures too, so they move with stocks more than the others (more on that below).

📅 2022's heroes: what came next?

Year-by-year returns show the strategy's personality clearly.

ETF20222023202420252026 (through Nov 19)
DBMF+21.53%-8.94%+7.25%+13.84%+14.86%
CTA(partial year)-2.25%+24.15%+0.89%-0.72%
KMLM+30.37%-5.66%-1.70%-3.02%+12.79%
IMF(not listed)(not listed)(not listed)(partial year)+12.55%
FMF+5.24%-0.17%+8.17%+4.55%+9.16%
WTMF-6.53%+16.70%+3.16%+12.16%+8.34%
For reference: SPY (S&P 500)-18.17%+26.19%+24.89%+17.72%+5.80%
For reference: AGG (US aggregate bonds)-13.02%+5.65%+1.31%+7.19%-1.03%
For reference: SGOV (T-bills)+1.58%+5.12%+5.27%+4.24%+3.28%

(Total return with distributions reinvested)

  • 🦸 They really were heroes in 2022. KMLM +30%, DBMF +22%, by shorting both stocks and bonds as they fell together.
  • 😮‍💨 Then 2023 and 2024 were hard. The S&P 500 gained 57% over those two years, while KMLM lost money both years and DBMF lost money in 2023. Rates stopped rising and chopped around, so trends kept breaking.
  • 🧗 KMLM was down three years in a row. It fell 27.6% from its October 2022 peak to June 2025 and still hasn't reclaimed that peak as of November 2026.
  • 🌅 2026 brought a comeback. DBMF +14.9%, KMLM +12.8%, IMF +12.6%, all ahead of the S&P 500 (+5.8%).
  • 🎲 The winner changes every year. KMLM led in 2022, WTMF in 2023, CTA in 2024. Different methods, different outcomes.

Here's how it looks over longer periods.

ETF1 year3 years5 yearsMax drawdownVolatility (3 yr)
DBMF+17.78%+35.22%+54.00%-20.44%11.16%
CTA-0.10%+20.21%(not listed)-20.79%18.78%
KMLM+16.15%+0.91%+25.83%-27.61%11.51%
IMF+18.70%(not listed)(not listed)-15.10%11.53%
FMF+9.36%+20.33%+28.11%-14.98%8.66%
WTMF+10.96%+29.27%+33.24%-13.21%9.53%
For reference: SPY+9.20%+64.66%+63.26%-24.50%15.48%
For reference: SGOV+3.74%+14.03%+21.03%-0.03%0.22%

(Close of November 19, 2026, total return with distributions reinvested. Max drawdown from October 25, 2021, or launch)

  • 📏 Over five years, DBMF came close to the S&P 500 (+54%), because it held on to most of its 2022 gains.
  • 🎢 Drawdowns of 13% to 28% rival stocks. This isn't a safe asset. It's an alternative that can swing as much as equities.

🌩️ Which crises do they handle, and which don't they?

The real story depends on what kind of crisis it is.

ETF2022 bear market (9 months)Mar 2023 SVB crisis (1 week)2025 tariff selloff (7 weeks)Nov 5, 2026 (1 day)
DBMF+31.54%-8.23%-7.18%-1.30%
CTA(not listed)-16.22%-6.67%0.00%
KMLM+47.73%-4.01%-2.77%-0.44%
FMF+13.99%-4.34%-3.84%+0.26%
WTMF-1.93%-0.73%-5.55%-1.28%
For reference: SPY-24.50%-2.42%-18.76%-4.41%
For reference: AGG-14.38%+2.75%+0.88%+0.25%
For reference: SGOV+0.75%+0.14%+0.56%0.00%

(Total return with distributions reinvested. The 2022 bear market runs from the S&P 500 peak on January 3 to the trough on October 12)

  • 🐢 They dominated the slow, grinding bear market. Over nine months in 2022, KMLM gained 48% and DBMF 32% by riding the big trends of rising rates and falling bonds.
  • ⚡ Most lost money in sudden selloffs. During SVB, rates reversed abruptly and positions betting on higher rates got hit. CTA lost 16% in a week.
  • 🧯 They're not "insurance that pays when stocks drop." In the tariff selloff and on November 5, they often fell alongside stocks.

Managed futures are less like fire insurance and more like gear for a long rainy season. 🌧️ They won't stop a sudden downpour (a crash), but they've shown their strength when the rain lasts for months.

🧩 What do they add to a portfolio?

The main reason to own managed futures is that they move independently of stocks. Here's each fund's correlation with the S&P 500 over three years (1 means moving together, 0 unrelated, -1 opposite).

ETFCorrelation with S&P 500 (3 yr)Why
CTA-0.12No equity futures, commodities and rates only
KMLM-0.03No equity futures
FMF0.1625% equity futures
DBMF0.34Copies the stock positions CTAs hold too
IMF0.38(since launch)
WTMF0.49Up to 40% equity futures
For reference: AGG0.17
For reference: RSST (stocks + managed futures)0.86Stacks managed futures on top of stocks
  • 🔀 KMLM and CTA moved almost independently of stocks, the strongest diversification of the group.
  • 📈 WTMF and DBMF lean toward stocks. They lag less in bull markets, but diversify less.
  • 🧱 "Return stacked" funds like RSST exist too. Each dollar buys about a dollar of stocks plus a dollar of managed futures, so it's really stocks plus an overlay. It gained 64% over three years, but with 24% volatility, more than stocks.

👍 Pros of managed futures

  • 🔀 They move differently from stocks and bonds, which helps in years when both fall (like 2022).
  • 🐢 They've been strong in long bear markets and inflationary periods.
  • 🔄 They can profit from rising and falling markets.

👎 Cons of managed futures

  • 😮‍💨 Slumps can last years. KMLM fell three years straight while stocks soared. Holding on is genuinely hard.
  • ⚡ They don't protect against sudden crashes, and often fell along with stocks.
  • 💸 They're expensive. Fees run 0.65% to 0.98%, far above index ETFs at around 0.03%.
  • 🎲 Results vary widely by fund. In the same year, one fund made 30% and another lost 7%. Don't pick on the "managed futures" label alone.

⚠️ Check before you invest

  • 🎁 Distributions can come in one big year-end payment. Futures gains are often paid out in a lump. Over the past year, DBMF yielded 5.0% (mostly in December), KMLM 4.5% (one December payment) and WTMF 8.2% (mostly in October). Buy just before the ex-date in a taxable account and you could get a tax bill on money that was already in the price.
  • 🧾 Check the tax treatment. Most of these funds hold futures through a Cayman Islands subsidiary so they can issue a 1099 instead of a K-1. How distributions are taxed depends on each fund's tax documents, and tax rules can change.
  • 🏦 Consider where you hold them. Because of the lumpy, often short-term distributions, some investors prefer tax-advantaged accounts for these funds.
  • 📜 Read the prospectus for the method and the markets. Whether a fund holds equity futures, runs pure trend, or replicates an index changes how it behaves.

Past returns and distributions don't guarantee future results.

🎁 The takeaway

Managed futures ETFs package CTA trend-following strategies as an alternative investment. In a year like 2022, when stocks and bonds fell together for months, KMLM gained 30% and DBMF 22%. But over the next two years, while stocks rose 57%, they went sideways or lost money, and they didn't stop sudden crashes. The data points to one way to use them: not as stock insurance, but as a piece that moves differently from stocks and bonds, sized so you can sit through a multi-year slump. And since methods differ so much, check whether a fund holds equity futures and whether it's pure trend before you buy. 😊

Want to explore more funds? Ask the search page something like "managed futures ETF" or "CTA ETF." 🚀