etfpick.me

Defensive Income ETFs, Tested in Two Sell-offs

ETF Strategies · Nov 3, 2026 · 6 min read

ETF Pick team

#defensive income#low volatility#dividend growth#buffer ETF#treasury#JEPIRead in Korean →

Contents ▾

In our last post, Can 4 Income ETFs Fund an Early Retirement?, we looked at high-yield option income funds. A lot of readers asked the opposite question. 🤔

"I don't need the biggest payout. Is there income that doesn't crater when the market does?"

So this time we're looking at defensive income ETFs: how much they actually fell in real sell-offs, and what they gave up in return. 📚

🛡️ What makes income "defensive"?

There's no official definition, so in this post we'll judge funds on three things:

  1. 📉 Smaller drops: When the market falls hard, they lose less (a smaller max drawdown).
  2. 💵 Steady cash: Distributions keep coming without wild swings.
  3. 🧘 A calmer ride: Day-to-day price moves (volatility) are smaller.

Think of it as walking instead of sprinting: you won't win the race, but you're less likely to fall. 🚶

Max drawdown is the biggest peak-to-trough drop over a period. A max drawdown of -20% means someone who bought at the worst possible moment was down 20% at one point.

🧩 Different ways to play defense

"Defensive" covers a lot of different approaches. What matters is what's doing the defending. 👀

  • 🏛️ Low-volatility high dividend: Dividend payers whose prices tend to move less, like utilities, consumer staples and REITs. Try low volatility dividend.
  • 🌱 Dividend growth: Companies with a long record of raising dividends, rather than the highest yield today. Search dividend growth.
  • 🎛️ Defensive premium income: Lower-volatility stocks plus option premium to boost the payout. JEPI is the best-known example. Try defensive equity premium income.
  • 🧱 Buffer (defined outcome): Uses options to absorb part of the index's losses over a set period, in exchange for a cap on gains. See buffer ETF.
  • 🏦 T-bills and short-term Treasuries: Very short maturities mean prices barely move, and the interest is paid out as distributions. Try short term treasury.

The rules differ a lot from fund to fund, so read the prospectus of anything you're considering. 🙏

📉 Test 1: The 2022 bear market

2022 was a tough year for defense. Rates rose fast, and stocks and bonds fell together. The S&P 500 lost 18.2%. Here's how defensive funds held up.

ETFType2022 returnMax drawdownVolatility5-year total return12-month yield
SPY (benchmark)S&P 500-18.2%-24.5%17.1%76.5%1.0%
SPHDLow-vol high dividend+0.6%-19.5%14.3%48.3%4.8%
LVHDLow-vol high dividend-1.8%-16.7%13.1%45.9%3.3%
SCHDDividend quality-3.2%-16.8%14.4%64.7%2.9%
DGRODividend growth-7.9%-19.3%13.7%71.5%1.8%
JEPIDefensive premium income-3.5%-13.7%11.0%43.4%8.6%
BUFRBuffer (laddered)-7.6%-13.7%10.5%58.2%0.0%
SGOV0-3 month T-bills+1.6%0.0%0.2%20.8%4.0%

(As of the Nov 2, 2026 close, etfpick.me data. Returns are total returns with distributions reinvested. The 5-year window starts Oct 25, 2021. Volatility is annualized. The 12-month yield is the last 12 months of distributions divided by the current price, before tax.)

What stands out: 👇

  • 🧘 High-dividend and premium income funds held near flat while the S&P 500 lost 18.2%.
  • 🐢 The trade-off shows up over five years. SPY returned 76.5%. SPHD returned 48.3% and JEPI 43.4%, a bit over half.
  • 🌱 Dividend growth funds sat in the middle. DGRO fell more in 2022 but kept up with SPY far better over five years (71.5%).
  • 🧱 BUFR cushioned the drop but paid nothing. A buffer is built for downside protection, not cash flow.

⚡ Test 2: The early-2025 sell-off

One test isn't enough, so let's look at a very different kind of drop. From Feb 19 to Apr 8, 2025, SPY fell 18.8% in about seven weeks.

ETFFeb 19 to Apr 8, 20252022 return
SPY-18.8%-18.2%
LVHD-6.5%-1.8%
SPHD-10.1%+0.6%
SCHD-12.9%-3.2%
BUFR-12.8%-7.6%
JEPI-13.3%-3.5%
DGRO-13.8%-7.9%
SGOV+0.6%+1.6%

(Total returns with distributions reinvested, etfpick.me data)

Every defensive fund lost less than SPY again, but the ranking changed. JEPI and SPHD were near the top in 2022 and further down in 2025, while LVHD did best this time. Defense depends on what kind of drop you're in, so don't expect one fund to win every time. 🔀

🔥 Does a high yield mean defensive?

Short answer: no. Yield and downside protection are two different things.

ETF12-month yieldFeb 19 to Apr 8, 20252022 return
QQQI15.0%-20.0%(not listed yet)
JEPQ13.2%-20.1%(not listed for the full year)
XYLD10.4%-15.5%-12.1%
PFF6.4%-7.5%-18.2%
LVHD3.3%-6.5%-1.8%

(As of the Nov 2, 2026 close. QQQI launched Jan 30, 2024, JEPQ May 4, 2022)

  • 💸 The Nasdaq-100 income funds QQQI and JEPQ pay 13% to 15%, yet they fell as much as SPY in early 2025. Covered calls still hold the stocks. For more on why, see Covered Call ETF Strategy, Made Simple. 📖
  • 🏦 Preferred stocks (PFF) look bond-like and pay 6.4%, but in 2022 they fell just as much as the S&P 500. They're sensitive to rising rates.

⚠️ Before you invest

  • 🛡️ Defensive doesn't mean loss-free. These funds fell less, not zero, and the ranking changes from one sell-off to the next.
  • 🐢 You'll likely lag in bull markets. Over five years, most defensive funds earned around half to three-quarters of SPY's return.
  • 🏦 Bonds and T-bills follow rates. Rising rates hurt bond prices, and falling rates shrink T-bill payouts.
  • 🧱 Know the buffer rules. Buffer funds have a set buffer, a cap and an outcome period, and buying mid-period changes what you get. They also pay little or nothing.
  • 🏷️ Don't judge by the label. "Income" funds built on a single stock's options are concentrated bets, not defensive holdings.
  • 🧾 Check the tax treatment. Option income and interest are often taxed differently from qualified dividends, which matters in a taxable account. Tax rules can change.

Past performance and distributions don't guarantee future results.

🎁 The takeaway

Defensive income means asking "how much could this fall?" before "how much does it pay?" In both the 2022 bear market and the early-2025 sell-off, these funds lost clearly less than the S&P 500, but they gave up a real chunk of the upside in between. Low-volatility dividends, dividend growth, premium income, buffers and T-bills each defend in different ways, so start with how big a drop you can live with and how much cash flow you need. 😊

Want to explore more? Try asking the search page something like "low volatility monthly dividend." 🚀