etfpick.me

100% Yields, Explained: Single-Stock Covered Call ETFs by the Numbers

ETF Strategies · Nov 4, 2026 · 6 min read

ETF Pick team

#single-stock covered call#covered call#option income#YieldMax#TSLY#NVDY#MSTYRead in Korean →

Contents ▾

"100% yield." "Paid every week." You've probably seen these headlines. 🤔 They're about covered call ETFs built on a single stock, like Tesla, NVIDIA or Palantir. The numbers look amazing on their own, but put them next to the stock itself and the picture changes. In this post we pull every day of data since launch to look at the trade-offs and when these funds actually work. 📚

New to covered calls? Start with Covered Call ETF Strategy, Made Simple. 📖

🎯 What's a single-stock covered call ETF?

Instead of an index like the Nasdaq-100 or S&P 500, these funds write covered calls on one company.

  1. 📈 They track one stock, like Tesla (many hold options that mimic the stock instead of the shares)
  2. ✍️ They sell call options on that stock and collect the premium
  3. 💵 They pay that premium out monthly, or even weekly

A single stock swings far more than an index. Bigger swings mean pricier options, which is how these funds post yields of 50% to over 100%. 💡

Try searching Tesla option income or single stock option income ETF to see what's out there.

📊 The report card since launch

Here are five of the biggest funds next to their stocks. ETF returns are total returns with every distribution reinvested.

ETF (stock)LaunchedStockETF total returnETF share price12-month yieldMax drawdown (ETF / stock)
TSLY (Tesla)Nov 2022+117.5%+49.6%-88.8%74.3%-49.3% / -53.8%
NVDY (NVIDIA)May 2023+623.2%+333.9%-43.3%54.3%-33.7% / -36.9%
MSTY (Strategy)Feb 2024+90.2%+58.8%-87.4%139.6%-77.0% / -82.6%
CONY (Coinbase)Aug 2023+83.7%+17.3%-92.3%131.7%-63.2% / -67.2%
PLTY (Palantir)Oct 2024+323.2%+174.2%-36.8%75.9%-41.0% / -48.2%

(As of the Nov 3, 2026 close, etfpick.me data. Stock prices from Nasdaq. ETF share prices are adjusted for reverse splits. Yields are before tax.)

What stands out: 👇

  • 📉 Total returns came in around half of the stock's. Even with every payout reinvested, all five earned less than simply holding the shares.
  • 🫠 Share prices collapsed. TSLY, MSTY and CONY are down close to 90% from launch. If you spent the distributions, that's roughly what happened to your principal.
  • 🛡️ The downside cushion was thin. Max drawdowns were only 3 to 7 points smaller than the stock's.

🌗 How much did they capture, up and down?

Next, we grouped every month by how much the stock moved, then looked at what the ETF did that same month. This pools all 192 months from the five funds.

Stock that monthMonthsStock avgETF avgCaptured
🚀 Surge (+15% or more)45+32.5%+22.3%69%
📈 Up (0 to +15%)67+6.2%+5.3%85%
📉 Down (-15% to 0)52-5.9%-4.6%78%
💥 Crash (below -15%)28-23.8%-19.8%83%

(ETF figures are total returns with distributions reinvested, month-end closes)

  • 🚀 In surge months, they missed about a third of the gain. Selling calls caps the upside.
  • 📉 In down months, they took about 80% of the loss. The premium is a cushion, but a thin one.
  • 😊 Steady, modest gains were the sweet spot. They captured 85% of the move and paid out on top.

In short: "less of the upside, most of the downside." That's why long-run total returns landed around half of the stock's. ⚖️

📅 Which years did the covered call win?

The yearly numbers make it clearer. Here's TSLY against Tesla.

YearTeslaTSLY total returnWinner
2023+101.7%+50.5%Stock
2024+62.5%+29.1%Stock
2025+11.4%+14.1%🏆 Covered call
2026 (through Nov 3)-11.4%-7.6%🏆 Covered call
  • 🏆 The covered call won in years when the stock didn't move much. The Amazon fund AMZY also beat Amazon in 2025, +10.5% versus +5.2%.
  • ⚠️ But choppy down years were worse. In 2025, Coinbase fell 8.9% while CONY lost 25.6%. After each sharp drop, the capped upside meant it missed much of the rebound.

💸 The payouts shrink too

A high yield sounds steady, but the dollars paid per share fell a lot. (Adjusted for reverse splits so the numbers compare per share.)

ETFFirst 12 months after launchLast 12 monthsChange
TSLY$85.19$16.69-80%
MSTY$159.06$18.63-88%
CONY$195.31$20.04-90%
NVDY$13.63$6.13-55%
PLTY$50.84$24.68-51%

Payouts are set relative to the share price at the time. When the price falls, the same yield pays fewer dollars. If you bought expecting a fixed monthly check, it could be much smaller a few years later. 🥲

Want to see more funds like these? Try NVIDIA option income. 🔍

🧭 So when do they make sense?

Here's what the data suggests.

Good fit 👍

  • 🙂 You expect the stock to drift sideways or rise slowly for a while, without big moves either way
  • 💵 You need cash flow now and can accept some erosion of principal
  • 🧩 You already hold plenty of stock and want to turn a slice of it into income

Poor fit 👎

  • 🚀 You think the stock is about to take off → owning the shares did far better
  • 🎢 You expect sharp drops and rebounds → you take the drops and miss the rebounds (CONY in 2025)
  • 🏦 It's money you can't afford to shrink, like retirement savings → these funds' share prices fell 37% to 92% since launch

⚠️ Before you invest

  • 🫠 Yield isn't return. A 100% yield doesn't help much if the share price falls 90%. Always check total return.
  • 🎯 It's one company. Far riskier than an index covered call. Whatever happens to that company happens to your fund.
  • 🔁 Reverse splits are common. When the price gets too low, several shares are combined into one. Don't panic if your share count drops.
  • 🧾 Check the tax treatment. Option income is often taxed differently from qualified dividends, and part of a payout may be classified as return of capital. In a taxable account, this matters. Tax rules can change.
  • 📜 Structures differ. Some funds hold options instead of shares, and strike choices and payout schedules vary. Read the prospectus.

Past performance and distributions don't guarantee future results.

🎁 The takeaway

A single-stock covered call ETF trades the stock's upside for cash flow today. In the data, these funds missed about a third of the gain in surge months and took about 80% of the loss in down months. Long-run total returns landed around half of the stock's, and anyone spending the payouts saw their principal shrink sharply. The data points to one use: a slice of your portfolio, on a stock you expect to stay fairly calm. 😊

Looking for something steadier? Ask the search page something like "index covered call monthly income." 🚀